From: Mike Viola [mviola@pppl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, July 08, 2003 4:21 PM To: Wayne Reiersen; Paul Goranson; Brad Nelson; Phil Heitzenroeder; Larry Sutton; Frank Malinowski; Hutch Heilson; Bob Keilbach; rparsells@pppl.gov; tbrown@pppl.gov; mjc@ornl.gov; abrooks@pppl.gov; fdahlgren@pppl.gov; jmalsbury@pppl.gov; jlevine@pppl.gov; ldudek@pppl.gov; sraftopoulos@pppl.gov; csuch@pppl.gov; rsimmons@pppl.gov; rstrykowsky@pppl.gov Cc: eperry@pppl.gov Subject: NCSX PVVS FDR On July 1 a meeting was held with PPPL, Rohwedder, and Major Tool representatives in attendance and ORNL representatives with Bob Keilbach in conference. Items discussed included the VVSA joint concepts, the VVSA geometry, a review of the FDR documentation (SOW, SPEC, and drawings), a demonstration of PPPL's present metrology capability and a tour of PPPL. The meeting was useful in conveying some of the concerns and restraints of the NCSX vacuum vessel design as well as getting input from the vendors. On July 8 the NCSX PVVS FDR was held (announcement below). The final signed off PVVS SOW, SPEC and promoted drawings were presented. It resulted in 5 chits and deemed successful. The design review documentation results (including attendee list) and chits are attached: In summary, the following issues were raised: 1) Verify that NEPA and USQD documentation is satisfactory - Wayne Reiersen 2) Plate welds will have the root on the inside - Mike Viola to convey 3) CHIT 1 Verify translation of models into fabrication CAM files - Larry Sutton to convey the following direction: Please include in your MIT/QA plan for the PVVS, steps for verifying your geometry as follows: a) Import our geometry in either step or native format. b) Send the file that you will develop for the PVVS fabrication to PPPL (in STEP if you are not using Pro-E, and in Pro-E native format otherwise). c) PPPL will perform a comparison check and advise if the files are approved for fabrication. 4) CHIT 2 Develop criteria for checking the model and perform that check - Mike Cole 5) CHIT 3 WBS12 to include analysis of gravity loads in October PDR - Paul Goranson 6) CHIT 4 Update the PVVS work plan job #1202 to include receipt QA inspection including dimensional check. - Mike Viola 7) CHIT 5 Update the PVVS work plan to include metrology development requirements and equipment procurement to meet those requirements - Paul Goranson Thank you all for your hard work in getting us through to this point. Mike >Date: Mon, 07 Jul 2003 11:10:39 -0400 >To: "Wayne Reiersen" , "Paul Goranson" >, "Brad Nelson" , "Phil >Heitzenroeder" , "Larry Sutton" , >"Frank Malinowski" , "Hutch Heilson" >, "Bob Keilbach" , >abrooks@pppl.gov, tbrown@pppl.gov, robert.keilbach@wgint.com, >rparsells@pppl.gov, "Cole, Michael J. (MJC)" , rsimmons@pppl.gov >From: Mike Viola >Subject: PVVS FDR tomorrow 9 AM >Cc: ldudek@pppl.gov > >CONFIRMED! >The FDR for the NCSX Prototype vacuum vessel PVVS is tomorrow >Tuesday July 8th morning at 9 AM in the Engineering Conference room. > >The signed off NCSX PVVS documents presented will be: >NCSX-SOW-121-01-02 >NCSX-CSPEC-121-01-01 >and promoted drawings: > >SE121-001P >SE121-002P >SE121-003P > >The chairman will be Bob Parsells. >Committee members will be: > >Tom Brown >Mike Cole >Paul Goranson >Brad Nelson >Wayne Reiersen > >Mike