From: Wayne T. Reiersen Sent: Monday, May 21, 2007 9:10 AM To: Marianne Tyrrell Subject: FW: Reminder... peer review at 2pm Attachments: Review Committee report.doc There was a peer review of the welded inboard shim design (WBS 142) on Friday, May 18. The announcement is listed below. Presentation material has been requested from Brad Nelson. The committee report is attached. The design was presented by Brad Nelson who is the RLM. The cog engineer is David Williamson. Attendees included Nelson, Cole, Williamson, Freudenberg, Fogarty, Reiersen, Brown, Brooks, Dudek, Viola, and Simmons. Please post. Wayne ________________________________ From: Wayne T. Reiersen Sent: Friday, May 18, 2007 12:53 PM To: Phil Heitzenroeder; Lawrence E. Dudek; Michael E. Viola; Arthur W. Brooks; Horng-Ming Fan; Bradley E. Nelson; mjc@ornl.gov; xdw@ornl.gov; Kevin Freudenberg; Thomas G. Brown Cc: Hutch Neilson; Mike Williams; Michael C. Zarnstorff; Robert A. Ellis; Erik D. Perry Subject: Reminder... peer review at 2pm Folks, Just a reminder that the ORNL folks will be unveiling the welded shim design at 2pm. I would like to treat this as a peer review in which we go through the process of collecting chits to ensure that all concerns get recorded. I will chair the review and ask Dudek, Brooks, Brown, and Heitzenroeder to also serve on the review committee. The purpose of this meeting is to determine if the welded shim option appears to be a sensible path forward and if so, what activities are needed to underpin and complete the design. See you at 2, Wayne