Major Tool & Machine, Inc.
Page: 1
 1458 East 19th Street
MTM N/C: 20871
Date: 12/14/06
 Indianapolis, IN 46218-4289
User ID: GRIFFITH

ENERGY INDUSTRIES OF OHIO
Customer:
Telephone:
216-496-2314
Contact:
NANCY HORTON
NKHFlowen@aol.com
E-Mail:
216-328-2001
Fax:

S005242-F/Ln:3
Customer P.O.:
SE141-115 / MODULAR COIL, TYPE B
Part:
B3
Serial No./Qty:
9
Revision:
SE141-115
Drawing ID:
W/O Links:
1-Type:W: 65708/3.0 Sub: 1 

317-636-6433
Telephone:
MIKE GRIFFITH
Reported By:
Fax:
317-634-9420
E-Mail:
mGriffith@MajorTool.com

Problem:
4 indications exceeding requirements of  ASTM A903M level 1.  Machined surfaces only.
#1 Line porosity, outer flange "E" side, 2.5" long.
#2 Line porosity, "D" side between holes 25-26 in the "T", 2.30" long.
#3 Line porosity, poloidal break, mating face, .700" long.
#4 Linear indication w/shrink cluster, "E" side wing O.D. .700" long.

Proposed Disposition:
MTM Proposed that indications be accepted As Is.

  2 page PT summary
Number of additional pages: 

Customer Disposition:       [X Use As Is          [  ] Rework          [  ] Repair          [  ] Scrap          [  ] Replace

Indication #1 is in the edge of the flange where the stress is low and can therefore be accepted as is.
Indication #2 is in the thick base section of the T in a low stress region.
Indication #3 is in the face section of the poloidal break and will be in compression, which inhibits crack growth and can therefore be accepted as is.  
Indication #4 is in a heavy wing section and can therefore be accepted because the crack will not grow through this piece during the machine lifetime.  

Title:
Date:

Major Tool Implemented By:

n:\mtmapps\Mtnonc14.qrp

Major Tool and Machine, Inc.  1458 East 19th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46218-4289  Tel: 317-636-6433  Fax: 317-634-9420