From: Arthur W. Brooks Sent: Wednesday, March 22, 2006 2:49 PM To: Michael E. Viola; Michael C. Zarnstorff; Wayne T. Reiersen; Bradley E. Nelson; 'Paul Goranson'; Phil Heitzenroeder; Lawrence E. Dudek; Thomas G. Brown; ' Michael J. Cole' Subject: RE: Points Violating 3 cm Minimum Clearance VV Outer Surface to FW Attachments: First Wall Encroachment.ppt Folks, The attached contains some 3D Bubble plots, ala Mike Cole & Brad, of the Points below that violate the minimum clearance to the from face of the First Wall (they are bigger spheres since the sphere radii represent the distance to the FW, not the out of tolerance). Art -----Original Message----- From: Arthur W. Brooks Sent: Monday, March 20, 2006 4:14 PM To: Michael E. Viola; Michael C. Zarnstorff; Wayne T. Reiersen; Mike Cole; Bradley E. Nelson; 'Paul Goranson'; Phil Heitzenroeder; Lawrence E. Dudek; Thomas G. Brown Subject: Points Violating 3 cm Minimum Clearance VV Outer Surface to FW Folks, Below is a tabulation of the Measurement Points taken by Major Tool that violate the minimum criteria of maintaining 3.0 cm from the Outer Surface of the VV Shell to the front face of the First Wall (or 2.05 cm from the VV Inner Surface or flange ID). The worse point is on the shell and is .3" too far in. I'll work with Mike Cole to plot these up in ProE. Art VV Shell Outer Surface. Minimum Distance to FW Required is 3.0 cm (1.181 in) Point# x y z measurement distance to FW , inches 1927 31.765700 -32.502100 8.365900 -0.146500 1.069603 1928 32.339000 -33.355100 9.199700 -0.152900 1.034970 1929 32.844500 -34.004100 9.822800 -0.178200 1.082073 1948 33.533000 -33.062100 9.245300 -0.092400 1.162143 1949 32.758000 -32.220600 8.357300 -0.098200 1.177325 6594 29.594200 -32.230800 7.807400 -0.201000 1.133137 6595 30.712800 -32.197100 7.961300 -0.140600 1.147084 6611 32.363100 -32.640300 8.698100 -0.060400 1.145220 6612 31.340700 -32.875100 8.666500 -0.129500 1.042877 6613 30.320500 -33.120700 8.677100 -0.221400 0.958413 6614 30.830700 -34.005100 9.455300 -0.287800 0.875583 6615 31.831300 -34.254800 9.847900 -0.226600 0.975567 6616 32.991600 -34.093700 9.996700 -0.126800 1.159719 6713 30.990600 33.992500 -9.839700 -0.005700 1.160567 End Flange Inner Surface. Minimum Distance to FW Required is 2.05 cm (0.806 in) Point# x y z measurement distance to FW , inches 10839 19.796300 39.048900 12.486900 0.195000 0.786773 10863 27.673800 33.085700 -8.125700 0.028100 0.766726 10864 28.344800 33.727700 -8.763300 0.038400 0.612232 10865 28.985800 34.332600 -9.347300 0.043400 0.559617 10866 29.668900 34.973500 -9.948600 0.037900 0.586234 10867 30.317500 35.592000 -10.510700 0.019700 0.705382 10898 29.331100 -34.753900 9.690300 0.083800 0.522243 10899 28.055400 -33.602800 8.580300 0.085600 0.595368 10900 27.437200 -32.999400 7.966500 0.081700 0.769793 10969 29.930100 -35.370200 10.270700 0.060900 0.612087 10970 30.561100 -35.998100 10.802700 0.051000 0.768699