From: Phil Heitzenroeder
Sent: Monday, December 20, 2004 4:19 PM
To: Bob Simmons
Subject: FW: Detail questions from EIO (We need to put into rapid
response)



-----Original Message-----
From: Phil Heitzenroeder 
Sent: Wednesday, November 24, 2004 1:11 PM
To: NKHFlowen@aol.com
Cc: Larry L. Sutton; David E. Williamson; Thomas G. Brown
Subject: FW: Detail questions from EIO

Nancy,
Reading the Weekly Report reminded me that I forgot to forward David's answers to Kevin's questions!  
Wishing you all a very happy Thanksgiving-
Phil

-----Original Message-----
From: David E. Williamson 
Sent: Monday, November 22, 2004 1:53 PM
To: Phil Heitzenroeder
Cc: Thomas G. Brown
Subject: RE: Detail questions

 
Phil,Tom,

I talked to Kevin by phone to get some clarification regarding question
#3:

The question refers to breakouts where a back spotface for the flange
thru hole is very close to a penetration in the shell.  This occurs in
3-4 places over the three winding forms.  Though the drawing calls out a
minimum spotface to clean up, the model has a fixed depth of cut, which
is how the machining will likely be done.  The options are to treat
these holes differently, eg create a true min spotface, or else de-burr
as required.  They would prefer the latter. It probably will look better
on the part because they will establish the depth of cut after measuring
the stocked flange surface for all of the holes.

On question #2, the cad model is correct and the drawing notes,
indicating the number of 3/8-16UNC holes, should be revised.

Question #1, the NBI opening mismatch is due to the assembly clearance
required at one end of the cutout. Mirror symmetry is not possible
because of the support boss at the other end, though stellerator
symmetry is preserved.  Kevin did not have a problem with the geometry
but was curious about it.

Let me know if further reponse documentation is required.

Thanks,
David


-----Original Message-----
From: Phil Heitzenroeder [mailto:PHeitzenroeder@pppl.gov] 
Sent: Friday, November 19, 2004 4:54 PM
To: Thomas G. Brown; Williamson, David E.
Cc: Nelson, Brad E.
Subject: FW: Detail questions

Tom,David-
Could you please answer the questions Kevin poses in the attached?
Thanks
Phil

-----Original Message-----
From: Bowling, Kevin [mailto:KBOWLING@majortool.com] 
Sent: Friday, November 19, 2004 2:24 PM
To: royjratc-aol-com-offsite
Cc: Smith, Rich; NKHFlowen@aol.com
Subject: Detail questions

Hello Roy: 

Please address the attached questions/comments. As we plow through the
details we will periodically find small things like the attached
graphic. I
will generally let a few of these accumulate until I pose the questions
unless they are work flow bottlenecks.

Best Regards, 
Kevin Bowling 
Program Manager 
Major Tool & Machine, Inc. 
Tel 317-917-2629 
Fax 317-634-9420 
kbowling@majortool.com 


<<11-19-04 questions.pdf>>