|
Review Title |
Prototype Modular Coil
Winding Form Peer
Review |
| Date |
23 January 2003 |
|
Cognizant Engineer |
Brad Nelson |
|
Responsible Line Manager |
Wayne Reiersen |
|
Review Board Chairperson |
Larry Dudek |
|
Review Board Members |
Jim Chrzanowski, Steve
Raftopoulos, B. Nelson (ORNL) Geoff Gettelfinger |
|
Invited Attendees |
P. Heitzenroeder, H.Neilson,
Larry Sutton, H.M. Fan, B. Simmons, D. Williamson (ORNL) |
|
Other Attendees |
R.Hawryluk, R. Strykowsky, W.
Reiersen, M. Zarnstorff, A.Brooks, T. Brown, M. Williams |
|
Charge |
|
|
Design Review Material |
Announcement
Presentation
Chits and Project
Disposition |
|
Review Board Report |
 |
|
Items Reviewed |
|
Sat |
Unsat |
Comments |
|
Appropriate requirements identified
|
|
|
|
|
Development plans and schedules |
|
|
|
|
Regulatory compliance including USQD and NEPA |
|
|
not presented |
|
Disposition of CHITS from previous reviews |
|
|
None |
|
Cost
objectives |
|
|
|
|
Other
review objectives addressed
(Attachment 4 of ENG-033) |
|
|
|
|
Summary of Results
|
This review was called prior to
the release of the design package to the coil winding form manufacturing
development subcontractor. The purpose of the review was to address
the poloidal break (flagged as an issue at the PAC meeting), the copper
cladding (a source of considerable expense and technical uncertainty in the
subcontractor proposal responses), and tolerances (ditto).
Recommendations on how these issues are to be addressed were presented at
the peer review. The schedule for the coil development and delivery
was also discussed.
Ten (10) Chits were generated
from this review. The chits were dispositioned following the review
and copies are attached. Once these chits are resolved and prior to
the release of the drawing package to the subcontractor a subgroup of this
review will be reconvened to review the final drawings.
|
|
Disposition
(check  one) |
Acceptable |
|
Acceptable pending resolution of concerns -
CHITS identified above must be resolved prior to installation. |
|
Incomplete -
Additional work is required prior to another design review.
|
|
Cog Engineer Close-out
(check
when done) |
|
|
|
